A telephone call is spontaneous: there is no advance notice of a call coming through. The most you can do is forewarn the servants (who act as a buffer) and hope they don't forget. An exception could be when you write to say that you will phone at a particular time. Thomas Hardy wrote to Lady St Helier in 1917, proposing "to ring you up on the telephone Wednesday morning to ask when we can call." Imagine the chaos today if we wrote to everyone first, announcing our intention to telephone them at a set time!
The visiting card represents its owner, the visitor. (Remember, you can't leave a card on behalf of another person who is out of town.) What represents the 'caller' when he telephones? In this respect, he is an unannounced visitor who contravenes social rules. Note also the slippage in meaning of the word 'caller': he is no longer a tangible presence in the house who sits opposite the hostess, but a disembodied voice heard coming from a handset. Implications for perceptions of the time-space relationship?
The rules for visiting are formal. Those who adhere to them are seen as upstanding members of polite society. What does it say about a person who bypasses these rules, engaging in innovations and uses a telephone?
The telephone's initial role was one of a business tool. Even when found in homes of the well-to-do, it was for the purpose of the householder/factory owner/businessman in communicating with his place of business. In this context, can we assume that the telephone has no place in polite society when ladies called on each other? Gentlemen rarely made such social visits, i.e. making morning calls.
A telephone call is (or at least, could be):
* uninvited
* unexpected
* unannounced
From a hostess's viewpoints, these are vulgar traits for a visitor.
November 21, 2010
Phones in the hallway
Visiting cards had to be deposited in a silver tray to be found on a hall table. They should never be handed directly to a servant nor to his mistress.
I find it amusing that Every Woman's Encyclopaedia advises its readers to place the telephone in the hall, even though the hall may be small and anyyone in the household can overhear phone conversations.
Visiting cards and telephone calls could be described as "invasions" or incursions into the private life of the family. They are unsolicited requests from friends/acquaintances to gain access to the inner sanctum of the family.
The hall could be seen as a half-way house between the public and private spheres of society. In the geography of the house, the hall is removed from the public gaze and any visitors/phone call that land in this 'prothalamos,' or ante-chamber, await further acceptance or rejection, screened from public view and unable to proceed further in the house's internal space.
For a long time, the phone's place in the family home has been the hall table. A ringing phone summons someone from the depths of the house. Phone calls have to be made in the (usually) dimly lit, unheated hall, which is a thoroughfare for everyone else to pass through. This is a public, shared area: it doesn't 'belong' to any one individual. There is no privacy or intimacy in using the telephone.
With the coming of cordless phones and extensions, the telephone handset could migrate further and become part of living room or bedroom furniture.
I find it amusing that Every Woman's Encyclopaedia advises its readers to place the telephone in the hall, even though the hall may be small and anyyone in the household can overhear phone conversations.
Visiting cards and telephone calls could be described as "invasions" or incursions into the private life of the family. They are unsolicited requests from friends/acquaintances to gain access to the inner sanctum of the family.
The hall could be seen as a half-way house between the public and private spheres of society. In the geography of the house, the hall is removed from the public gaze and any visitors/phone call that land in this 'prothalamos,' or ante-chamber, await further acceptance or rejection, screened from public view and unable to proceed further in the house's internal space.
For a long time, the phone's place in the family home has been the hall table. A ringing phone summons someone from the depths of the house. Phone calls have to be made in the (usually) dimly lit, unheated hall, which is a thoroughfare for everyone else to pass through. This is a public, shared area: it doesn't 'belong' to any one individual. There is no privacy or intimacy in using the telephone.
With the coming of cordless phones and extensions, the telephone handset could migrate further and become part of living room or bedroom furniture.
Labels:
hall,
public-private,
visiting
November 20, 2010
Established rules of etiquette
There were certain situations where you just knew that you could expect a visit one day soon. An acquaintance has come to town and the rules dictate that they must pay you a visit.
If visiting cards are left for you by your visitor, you can decide whether you want to be "at home" or not. A modern equivalent might be screening all incoming phone calls with 'caller ID' and then deciding whether to answer or not. Or perhaps refusing to answer the front door, pretending that you're not at home.
Calling hours were specific (3.00pm-6.00pm: perversely called 'morning calls' but only because they take place before dinner). Visits had to be repaid within a set time limit.
No cards should be sent by post - the height of vulgarity!
Servants must differentiate between:
* a card left after a visitor leaves
* a card left and the caller enquires if the mistress is at home
Purpose of calling cards: to get round the tiresome problem of servants with amnesia.
Semantics: when a card is left with a turned-down corner, this means the visitor will call on the mother and her daughters together.
Duration of visit: never to exceed 15 minutes.
Embarrassment: what do you do if another visitor calls while you are visiting. Stay, leave, talk, be silent?
Cards are also left at a family's house when an acquaintance dies.
A married lady would also leave her husband's visiting card together with hers - unless he was out of town (if, say, he were a naval officer serving overseas). Your card is your proxy. It is the rule that wives do the card-leaving for their husbands. Married men rarely call in person!
After a visit, the calling card is left on the hall table. It is never handed direct to a servant or the hostess.
The style and content of the visiting card must be fixed and simple - no ornate curlicues or fonts or elaborate use of titles.
The Girls' Own Paper, 1880. Vol. I
Manners and rules of good society, or solecisms to be avoided. London: Frederick Warne, 1916.
Routledge's Manual of Etiquette.
Every Woman's Encyclopaedia. Vol. VI
If visiting cards are left for you by your visitor, you can decide whether you want to be "at home" or not. A modern equivalent might be screening all incoming phone calls with 'caller ID' and then deciding whether to answer or not. Or perhaps refusing to answer the front door, pretending that you're not at home.
Calling hours were specific (3.00pm-6.00pm: perversely called 'morning calls' but only because they take place before dinner). Visits had to be repaid within a set time limit.
No cards should be sent by post - the height of vulgarity!
Servants must differentiate between:
* a card left after a visitor leaves
* a card left and the caller enquires if the mistress is at home
Purpose of calling cards: to get round the tiresome problem of servants with amnesia.
Semantics: when a card is left with a turned-down corner, this means the visitor will call on the mother and her daughters together.
Duration of visit: never to exceed 15 minutes.
Embarrassment: what do you do if another visitor calls while you are visiting. Stay, leave, talk, be silent?
Cards are also left at a family's house when an acquaintance dies.
A married lady would also leave her husband's visiting card together with hers - unless he was out of town (if, say, he were a naval officer serving overseas). Your card is your proxy. It is the rule that wives do the card-leaving for their husbands. Married men rarely call in person!
After a visit, the calling card is left on the hall table. It is never handed direct to a servant or the hostess.
The style and content of the visiting card must be fixed and simple - no ornate curlicues or fonts or elaborate use of titles.
The Girls' Own Paper, 1880. Vol. I
Manners and rules of good society, or solecisms to be avoided. London: Frederick Warne, 1916.
Routledge's Manual of Etiquette.
Every Woman's Encyclopaedia. Vol. VI
Etiquette - good telephone manners
Nineteenth-century British society is governed by a set of rules with a rigid format. These rules determine (among other things) who may call on whom, and when; how visiting cards are to be used; how to interact with a family that has suffered a bereavement; how to give and receive invitations; and hundreds of other situations.
In the Fin de Siecle period, these rules are gradually relaxed, an atmosphere of informality begins to appear where people do not insist so much on social norms being enforced.
It is in this same period that the telephone makes its appearance in society. Coincidentally, it is used in those circles where social manners were/are considered important. (Not that the 'lower classes' didn't have their own social codes; they did, but their codes were untouched by the initial telephone's appearance. Other technologies shaped their daily lives.)
My question - did the presence of the telephone in these people's houses play any fundamental, primary role in relaxing (or, subverting?) existing rules of etiquette? Or did other factors come into play (e.g. the various changes in society that can be lumped together under the heading of Modernity)? In other words, is the telephone the cause or the symptom of the erosion in social manners during this era?
In a domestic situation, the telephone starts off as a tool for 'business' (the business of running a household): ringing to place grocery orders, etc. Prior to this, of course, it allowed the gentleman of the house to keep in touch with his place of business (his home is an 'extended office'). The telephone then ends up as a tool for conducting social relationships (giving invitations, asking after friends, etc.)
Then, as now, people express concerns about bad manners in phone use or the phone's intrusiveness in the domestic sphere. See:
* Gary Marx. "New telecommunications require new manners." Telecoms Policy 1994 18(7); 538-551.
* Minna T. Antrim, “Outrages of the telephone,” Lippincotts’ Monthly Magazine Vol 84 (July 1909), 125-26.
* Maude A. White, “‘Those Telephonics.’ Have you one in your home?” Delineator, Vol 96 (May 1920).
Sometimes, the new technology appears and embeds itself in social practice so quickly that it takes a while for the rules of good behaviour to catch up with reality and set out some ground rules for basic use. A similar phenomenon is observed nowadays with mobile phones, e-mails, etc. (when should mobiles be turned off, do we treat e-mails like paper memos, etc.)
Dematerialization of telecommunication
How does "being connected globally" affect local development?
Appearance and spread of telegraph coincided with:
*growing global trade links [connections]
*increasing volume of trade [quantity, volume]
A close link exists between:
*development of telegraph in a region
*the region's position in world trade
Global spread of telegraphy has positive effects on world trade.
When communications and transport are separated a new virtual space is created.
In this new virtual space, relations between time and space are changed.
A new technology will spread and be adopted only when:
*there is a demand for it
*the new tech. offers clear advantages over the other alternatives
Public demand must be balanced against the effects of "technological inertia" (Mokyr).
Railway expansion created need for telegraph in order to co-ordinate trains.
per Castells
A network has no centre and therefore no periphery.
No single node is essential to the network.
If a node fails, the network reconfigures and works around the failed node.
Some nodes are more important than other nodes.
Telegraphy spreads quickly:
*Railway companies see the benefits and (no longer put off by high costs) erect lines along railway tracks [---> cumulative action of technologies; ---> mutual benefits for both telegraph and railway companies]
*Newspapers exploit telegraphy for obtaining news more quickly
*Law enforcement forces use telegraphy to fight crime -- a telegram is quicker than a murderer!
Parallels can be seen between social networks [connections among people] and telecommunications networks. In both networks, some nodes are:
*more important than other nodes;
*closer to the flow of information than other nodes.
A word of caution re. the analogy of social networks for comm. networks. The connections in social networks only register when interaction/communication between two nodes occurs. A similar connection between two nodes in a comm. network registers the potential for communication, i.e. the nodes exist but a flow of information may not be present during our examination. The infrastructure is in place but the information flow is not necessarily present or continuous.
In order to describe a country as a communications centre, it needs:
*an advanced domestic telegraph system
*good connections to other foreign networks
Roland Wenzlhuemer. "The dematerialization of telecommunication: communication centres and peripheries in Europe and the world, 1850-1920." Journal of Global History (2007) 2, 345-372.
Appearance and spread of telegraph coincided with:
*growing global trade links [connections]
*increasing volume of trade [quantity, volume]
A close link exists between:
*development of telegraph in a region
*the region's position in world trade
Global spread of telegraphy has positive effects on world trade.
When communications and transport are separated a new virtual space is created.
In this new virtual space, relations between time and space are changed.
A new technology will spread and be adopted only when:
*there is a demand for it
*the new tech. offers clear advantages over the other alternatives
Public demand must be balanced against the effects of "technological inertia" (Mokyr).
Railway expansion created need for telegraph in order to co-ordinate trains.
per Castells
A network has no centre and therefore no periphery.
No single node is essential to the network.
If a node fails, the network reconfigures and works around the failed node.
Some nodes are more important than other nodes.
Telegraphy spreads quickly:
*Railway companies see the benefits and (no longer put off by high costs) erect lines along railway tracks [---> cumulative action of technologies; ---> mutual benefits for both telegraph and railway companies]
*Newspapers exploit telegraphy for obtaining news more quickly
*Law enforcement forces use telegraphy to fight crime -- a telegram is quicker than a murderer!
Parallels can be seen between social networks [connections among people] and telecommunications networks. In both networks, some nodes are:
*more important than other nodes;
*closer to the flow of information than other nodes.
A word of caution re. the analogy of social networks for comm. networks. The connections in social networks only register when interaction/communication between two nodes occurs. A similar connection between two nodes in a comm. network registers the potential for communication, i.e. the nodes exist but a flow of information may not be present during our examination. The infrastructure is in place but the information flow is not necessarily present or continuous.
In order to describe a country as a communications centre, it needs:
*an advanced domestic telegraph system
*good connections to other foreign networks
Roland Wenzlhuemer. "The dematerialization of telecommunication: communication centres and peripheries in Europe and the world, 1850-1920." Journal of Global History (2007) 2, 345-372.
Labels:
Castells,
Mokyr,
space/time,
telegraph
November 14, 2010
Anthony Trollope and the telegraph girls
"The Young Women at the London Telegraph Office"
from Good Words, June 1877
Details of the girls' employment used as background info. for Trollope's short story "The Telegraph Girl."
The impression that comes out is that these young women are lucky to enjoy a position in the Civil Service and all the benefits that accrue. At this point in time, this is perhaps one of only a few rare occasions where a woman could work in a male/middle-class dominated domain.
Trollope states outright that he is not really interested in the technical side of the girls' work; he is looking for a human-interest story. He is more concerned with the social aspects of their occupation - what brought them to work at the telegraph office, what is their behaviour like, do they flirt with the the few boys that work in the same room, and so on. He poses many rhetorical questions of this nature but provides no answers. I get the impression that what answers he does provide of a social nature, are based on supposition. He presumably had a guided tour (ordinarily, members of the public are not allowed in, nor are the girls allowed visitors) and his guide would have provided the basics: wages, hours of work, pension scheme. For the rest, modesty prevented him from questioning the girls about personal matters.
The office is a 'half-way house' and the girls re-transmit telegrams coming from other offices that are destined for elsewhere. "They live secluded and apart, in a world of their own, harassed by no interruptions from without." In other words, there is no contact with the public, which makes this job respectable enough for girls from good, respectable families. Taking their lunch in the company canteen protects them further from public gaze in the high street tea room.
In addition to the entrance exams that test reading, writing and maths, the applicant has to provide three character references.
Lateness is not tolerated and records are kept of late arrival. A girl who arrives late for work could mean the delayed dispatch of an important telegram. Trollope's example shocked me: supposing a gentleman wanted his horse brought round so he could go fox hunting and this message didn't get through in time? He would miss the hounds!!! Couldn't Trollope have found a less vain example, something to do with, say, closing a business deal, or notice of a sickness/death?
Generally, I am highly suspicious of texts written by authors of fiction, even when they purport to be documentary. Trollope may present 'facts' but he does so with an eye to a good read and we can never be sure what his true agenda is.
from Good Words, June 1877
Details of the girls' employment used as background info. for Trollope's short story "The Telegraph Girl."
The impression that comes out is that these young women are lucky to enjoy a position in the Civil Service and all the benefits that accrue. At this point in time, this is perhaps one of only a few rare occasions where a woman could work in a male/middle-class dominated domain.
Trollope states outright that he is not really interested in the technical side of the girls' work; he is looking for a human-interest story. He is more concerned with the social aspects of their occupation - what brought them to work at the telegraph office, what is their behaviour like, do they flirt with the the few boys that work in the same room, and so on. He poses many rhetorical questions of this nature but provides no answers. I get the impression that what answers he does provide of a social nature, are based on supposition. He presumably had a guided tour (ordinarily, members of the public are not allowed in, nor are the girls allowed visitors) and his guide would have provided the basics: wages, hours of work, pension scheme. For the rest, modesty prevented him from questioning the girls about personal matters.
The office is a 'half-way house' and the girls re-transmit telegrams coming from other offices that are destined for elsewhere. "They live secluded and apart, in a world of their own, harassed by no interruptions from without." In other words, there is no contact with the public, which makes this job respectable enough for girls from good, respectable families. Taking their lunch in the company canteen protects them further from public gaze in the high street tea room.
In addition to the entrance exams that test reading, writing and maths, the applicant has to provide three character references.
Lateness is not tolerated and records are kept of late arrival. A girl who arrives late for work could mean the delayed dispatch of an important telegram. Trollope's example shocked me: supposing a gentleman wanted his horse brought round so he could go fox hunting and this message didn't get through in time? He would miss the hounds!!! Couldn't Trollope have found a less vain example, something to do with, say, closing a business deal, or notice of a sickness/death?
Generally, I am highly suspicious of texts written by authors of fiction, even when they purport to be documentary. Trollope may present 'facts' but he does so with an eye to a good read and we can never be sure what his true agenda is.
November 13, 2010
Census returns
www.histpop.org
National census returns with occupational details (working for telegraph/telephone companies, messengers, etc.), ordered by region, city, age, gender.
National census returns with occupational details (working for telegraph/telephone companies, messengers, etc.), ordered by region, city, age, gender.
Labels:
census,
occupation
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)